Why Hiring Beyond the Checklist Builds Stronger Teams

​When it comes to hiring, it’s tempting for managers to fall back on a checklist: a set number of years’ experience, a specific industry background, or an exact match of technical skills. While these requirements may feel like the “safe” option, they can actually limit opportunities to bring fresh ideas and perspectives into a team.

The truth is, some of the most impactful hires come from people who didn’t follow a straight line in their careers. Instead of narrowing down your options to one type of candidate, embracing diverse backgrounds can create stronger, more innovative teams.

The Problem with “Checklist Hiring”

Rigid job requirements often cause businesses to overlook exceptional talent. By only searching within one industry, you not only shrink the talent pool but also miss out on candidates who bring transferable skills, adaptability, and creativity gained from other sectors.

Research supports this: according to the Australian Human Rights Commission, organisations that embrace diversity in experience and background are more innovative, resilient, and better at problem-solving. In marketing and advertising, especially, fresh perspectives can spark campaigns and strategies that stand out in an increasingly crowded landscape.

Fresh Perspectives in Action

At Stopgap, we’ve seen the power of diverse career journeys first-hand.

Our Principal Consultant, Larisa, began her career in pharmaceuticals before moving into automotive and then shopper/retail promotions. Each shift gave her new insights and skills, and today, she leverages that breadth of experience to connect clients with talent in ways that feel fresh and strategic.

Similarly, before moving into recruitment, Hils built her career in marketing with global powerhouses such as Warner Bros., Sony Pictures, and Disney in London. Now, as a Senior Consultant, she draws on that expertise to support clients in finding standout talent aligned with their goals at all levels.

These examples highlight that diverse career paths are not roadblocks, they’re accelerators. People who’ve worked across different industries bring agility, new ways of thinking, and the ability to solve challenges from angles others may not see.

​

Why Hiring for Diversity of Experience Matters

In today’s market, where adaptability and innovation are critical, hiring someone who ticks every box on a checklist may not always be the smartest move. Instead, consider what else a candidate brings:

• Broader problem-solving skills from varied industries

• Adaptability built through career shifts

• Creative approaches inspired by fresh perspectives

• A deeper ability to connect with diverse audiences

These qualities are often what set great teams apart from good ones.

​

Final Thought

The strongest teams aren’t built by ticking boxes, they’re built by embracing people who offer something different. By being open to candidates from varied industries and backgrounds, hiring managers can unlock fresh ideas, create more resilient teams, and ultimately drive better results.

At Stopgap, we see it every day: people with diverse experiences are often the very ones who transform businesses.

​

Sources

• Australian Human Rights Commission – Leading for Change: A Blueprint for Cultural Diversity and Inclusive Leadership

• Diversity Council Australia – Cracking the Glass-Cultural Ceiling

• Harvard Business Review – Why Diverse Teams Are Smarter